Toscanella Village Cafe

Nestled in the heart of Middletown Township, NJ, Toscanella Village Cafe is a beloved pizza restaurant that masterfully combines authentic Italian flavors with generous portions and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're craving classic pizzas or hearty Italian pastas, Toscanella offers a diverse menu that caters to every palate.

Step inside, and you'll immediately feel at home in the spacious yet cozy setting—much larger than it appears from the outside—with distinct areas for casual grab-and-go slices or a relaxed sit-down meal. This versatility makes it perfect for everything from a quick lunch to a leisurely family dinner.

The menu is a treasure trove of Italian comfort food favorites. For pizza enthusiasts, options like the crispy Sicilian pizza and the perfectly balanced Grandma style stand out, while their plain and specialty pizzas cater to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike. Pasta lovers aren’t left behind—mouthwatering dishes such as Penne Vodka, Fettuccine Alfredo, and the robust Meat Lasagna deliver rich, comforting flavors that linger delightfully on the palate.

Don’t miss signature specialties like the Veal PJ or the fresh and vibrant Toscanella Salad, which perfectly balances the indulgence of their richer dishes. Lunch offerings are notably inviting, with affordable yet generous portions of classics like Baked Ziti, Spaghetti and Meatballs, and Gnocchi that showcase the chef’s skill in blending freshness with heartiness.

Customers rave about the quality of ingredients and perfectly crafted dishes. Marty Mervin praised their Father’s Day Menu Special as “exceptional,” noting both the generous portions and outstanding flavor. Carley Palmer’s experience with the lasagna highlights the freshness and perfect cheese balance, while Michelle Bautista’s enthusiasm for everything from pizzas to stuffed salmon speaks volumes about the consistent quality and flavorful variety available. Regular Sean Shenefield affectionately calls Toscanella a “hidden gem” with reasonable prices and remarkable food that keeps his family coming back week after week.

Whether you’re stopping in for a savory single slice or settling down to indulge in a full Italian feast, Toscanella Village Cafe promises an authentic taste experience paired with warm, friendly service. Its inviting ambiance and thoughtfully crafted dishes make it a standout gem in the Middletown dining scene—the kind of place that fills you with satisfaction long after the last bite.